[转帖]墨大编纂澳洲大学排行榜

Iceape · 发表于 14-2-2005 19:57:42|来自：新加坡

墨爾本大學最近趁熱打鐵，發表了一篇半學術半廣告的研究論文《The International Standing of Australian Universities》。整個排名從分數上看呈現六階梯，澳洲一流大學是毫無爭議的澳囯大，墨大和悉大。它的排名用了很多Criteria,表面看起來非常合理，但其中不少是墨大文胸裏莫需有的海棉，而且墨爾本大學在數據採用的時机上做了小動作,，如果用上年或上上年的數據，這排行榜可能就面目全非了。不過,Any Ranking is Imperfect,我個人覺得這個排名比任何排名都更接近事實，因此就我個人來説，I will Take it Seriously.
University of Melbourneourne Institute Index of the International Standing
of Australian Universities

Group University / Weighted Score / Rank
<HR color=#000080 SIZE=3>

First Class 
Australian National University 100 1
University of Melbourne 100 1
University of Sydney 95 3
<HR color=#000080 SIZE=3>

Second Class
University of Queensland 87 4
University of New South Wales 85 5
<HR color=#000080 SIZE=3>

Third Class
Monash University 76 6
University of Western Australia 76 6
University of Adelaide 70 8
<HR color=#000080 SIZE=3>

Fourth Class
Flinders University of South Australia 56 9
La Trobe University 55 10
Macquarie University 54 11
University of Tasmania 53 12
University of Newcastle 52 13
Murdoch University 51 14
University of Wollongong 50 15
<HR color=#000080 SIZE=3>

Fifth Class
Curtin University of Technology 49 16
Griffith University 49 16
Queensland University of Technology 49 16
Deakin University 47 19
University of New England 47 19
University of Technology,Sydney 47 19
James Cook University 46 22
Swinburne University of Technology 46 22
University of South Australia 44 24
RMIT University 43 25
University of Canberra 42 26
Charles Darwin University 41 27
Edith Cowan University 41 27
Victoria University 41 27
<HR color=#000080 SIZE=3>

Sixth Class
Charles Sturt University 39 30
Southern Cross University 39 30
University of Western Sydney 39 30
University of Ballarat 38 33
Australian Catholic University 37 34
Central Queensland University 37 34
University of Southern Queensland 36 36
University of Notre Dame, Australia 32 37
University of the Sunshine Coast 32 37

　 
其他分項排名
<HR color=#000000>

口碑排名
在這次研究中，墨爾本大學向各澳洲大學的校長和外國著名大學的CEO發出調查問卷，要他們對澳洲大學評分，在回應的40份答卷中結果如下。
Group University/Foreign CEOs/Deans Ratings
University of Melbourne 100.0 96.5
Australian National University 94.7 100.0
University of Sydney 79.6 91.0 
University of Queensland 54.9 87.3 
University of New South Wales 62.4 79.0 
Monash University 54.0 67.5
University of Western Australia 38.1 68.2 
University of Adelaide 45.1 51.3 
Macquarie University 19.0 38.5 
University of Tasmania 19.9 36.0 
La Trobe University 21.7 32.0 
Queensland University of Technology 20.4 29.8 
Flinders University of South Australia 17.3 34.8 
Griffith University 15.5 34.7 
RMIT University 16.8 29.2 
Curtin University of Technology 17.7 26.1 
University of Technology,Sydney 14.6 31.7 
 University of Newcastle 15.0 30.8 
Deakin University 17.7 26.7 
University of New England 18.1 25.1
University of Wollongong 13.7 30.6 
James Cook University 15.0 26.8 
University of Canberra 19.0 18.1 
University of South Australia 14.2 24.8 
Murdoch University 12.8 25.4 
Victoria University 11.1 16.0 
Edith Cowan University 9.3 17.3 
Central Queensland University 9.7 14.6 
Bond University 6.2 17.7 
Charles Darwin University 8.4 14.1 
University of Western Sydney 6.6 17.5 
Charles Sturt University 5.3 17.2 
Swinburne University of Technology 5.3 15.8 
Australian Catholic University 5.8 13.3 
University of Southern Queensland 4.9 15.2 
Southern Cross University 4.0 13.3 
University of the Sunshine Coast 4.4 11.6 
University of Ballarat 3.5 12.7 
University of Notre Dame, Australia 2.7 11.9 
<HR color=#000000>

整體師資排名（International Standing of Staff）

1 University of Melbourne 100
2 Australian National University 95.1
3 University of Sydney 94.5
4 University of Queensland 77
5 University of New South Wales 73.6
6 Monash University 61.1
7 University of Western Australia 50.9
8 University of Adelaide 43.8
9 La Trobe University 25.2
10 University of Newcastle 22.9
11 Flinders University of South Australia 20.3
12 University of Tasmania 19.1
13 Macquarie University 17.1
14 Griffith University 16.9
15 Queensland University of Technology 14.8
16 Curtin University of Technology 13.1
17 University of Wollongong 12.6
18 Deakin University 12.4
19 Murdoch University 11.9
20 University of New England 11.2
21 James Cook University Cook 11
22 University of Technology,Sydney 10.3
23 University of South Australia 9.8
24 University of Western Sydney 8.6
25 RMIT University 7.9
26 Edith Cowan University 5.9
27 Charles Sturt University 5
28 Victoria University 4.4
29 Swinburne University of Technology 4
30 University of Canberra 2.9
31 Southern Cross University 2.4
32 Central Queensland University 1.7
33 University of Southern Queensland 1.5
34 Australian Catholic University 1.4
35 Charles Darwin University 1.3
36 University of Ballarat 1
37 University of Notre Dame, Australia 0.3
38 University of the Sunshine Coast 0.3

<HR color=#000000>

研究生課程排名（Graduate Program）

1 University of Melbourne 100
2 University of Sydney 97.1
3 University of Queensland 94
4 University of New South Wales 90.8
5 Monash University 88.2
6 Australian National University 82
7 University of Western Australia 78.4
8 University of Adelaide 76.2
9 Queensland University of Technology 74.5
10 Macquarie University 73.3
11 La Trobe University 73.2
12 Swinburne University of Technology 72.5
13 Flinders University of South Australia 72.2
14 Southern Cross University 70.4
15 University of Wollongong 70
16 Edith Cowan University 69.6
17 Griffith University67.6
18 University of Tasmania 67.3
19 Curtin University of Technology 66.9
20 University of Technology,Sydney 66.3
21 University of Newcastle 66
22 Murdoch University 65.8
23 Deakin University 65.1
24 University of South Australia 64.4
25 Charles Darwin University 63.4
26 James Cook University Cook 62.1
27 University of New England 60.6
28 University of Canberra 60.2
29 Victoria University 58.8
30 RMIT University 58.7
31 University of Ballarat 56.6
32 Australian Catholic University 56
33 Charles Sturt University 55.9
34 University of Western Sydney 55.4
35 University of Southern Queensland 54.5
36 Central Queensland University 53
37 University of Notre Dame, Australia 29.3
38 University of the Sunshine Coast 28.4

<HR color=#000000>

本科課程排名（Undergraduate Program）

1 University of Western Australia 100
2 University of Sydney 95.6
3 University of Queensland 95.5
4 University of Adelaide 94.8
5 Murdoch University 94.8
6 University of Melbourne 94.2
7 University of New South Wales 94.1
8 Australian National University 90.7
9 Monash University 90.2
10 Flinders University of South Australia 89.9
11 Victoria University 89.6
12 Macquarie University 87.6
13 University of Wollongong 86.1
14 University of New England 84.3
15 La Trobe University 83.5
16 University of Canberra 83
17 Swinburne University of Technology 82.8
18 University of Tasmania 82.6
19 Griffith University 82.2
20 Curtin University of Technology 82.2
21 University of Notre Dame, Australia 78.5
22 University of Newcastle 77.9
23 University of Technology,Sydney 77.8
24 Southern Cross University 77.7
25 University of South Australia 77.4
26 Australian Catholic University 76.7
27 University of the Sunshine Coast 74.8
28 Deakin University 74.4
29 University of Southern Queensland 73.3
30 RMIT University 72.6
31 Queensland University of Technology 71.7
32 University of Ballarat 71
33 Edith Cowan University 69.8
34 Charles Sturt University 69.7
35 University of Western Sydney 69.6
36 James Cook University Cook 69.3
37 Charles Darwin University 69.1
38 Central Queensland University 64


從墨爾本大學的研究結果來看，根據原始分澳洲綜合第一應該是墨爾本大學（100分），第二名是澳囯大(98.1)，第三名是悉尼大學(95.3),其他大學基本沒有和Top 3競爭的能力，第四和第三相差近10分。而從聲譽來説，也是如上的排序。至於教書育人，澳洲最好的地方應該是悉尼大學。
墨爾本大學這次排名，按他自己的話説是
“
Our survey results exhibit a common view within Australia
and overseas that the measurement of standing should not be confined to research
performance; indeed, the general consensus was that the international standing of
academic staff as measured by research performance should have a weight of less
than 50 per cent. But this weight underestimates the importance of first-rate
academic staff; other personal attributes such as teaching and supervision excellence
are reflected in our measures of the quality of the undergraduate and graduate
programs.
”
墨爾本大學是一閒很狡猾的大學,它在此時此刻推出這樣一篇廣告論文明顯是別有用心的--- ---墨爾本今年在研究資金的爭奪中是表現最好的一年,而它的口碑也建校以來最好的一年,Thanks to 上交和Times這兩顆子彈.而在歷史上為自己留下一篇勇奪No.1的論文自是一件飃飃慾仙的美事。我覺得如果用更客觀的數據，更合理的評分比例，NO.1是另有其人的，第一階梯也不會有ANU這所不懂教學的研究院.
　
最後的提醒就是：
如果只看原始分墨爾本大學是100分，ANU是98分，後來經過沒有公開調分步驟，ANU和墨爾本都變了100分，這樣排行榜可信度無疑就高了，它再次認證了兩顆子彈的真實性。
--- --- 司馬昭之心路人皆知。

[转帖]墨大编纂澳洲大学排行榜

发表回复

精选推荐